Skip to main content

Featured Post

2023 - The Year That Was

Places impact you for a variety of reasons. And the same place impacts different people in different ways. This is especially true when it comes to spiritual experiences, where every single person’s experience is unique. And personally, every spiritual experience is unique, the same person can have different deeply spiritual experiences at different places, at different times. This thought has emerged because of my own experiences over the years, but especially so this year, with different and unique experiences at various places I have visited recently. I began this year with a visit to Baroda (Vadodara) with friends. It was meant to be a relaxed trip, a touristy trip, with our sons. We enjoyed ourselves to the hilt, but the highlight of that trip was a visit to the Lakulisha temple at Pavagadh. It was the iconography of the temple that I connected with, and I spent a few hours simply lost in the details of the figures carved around the temple. There was an indefinable connect with

Book Review: On Philosophising, Philosophers, Philosophy and New Vistas in Applied Philosophy, by Dr. Sharmila Jayant Virkar

A little bit of context before you begin reading this book review. I have recently enrolled for an MA in Philosophy at the University of Mumbai. Philosophy is something I have been getting interested in, over the past few years, as those of you who have been reading my blogs and Instagram posts would know. During the pandemic, I thought long and hard about what I wanted to do next, and this is what I eventually came up with. It has been a challenge, getting back into academics as a student at this age, especially in a subject I have no academic background in. However, it has also been very exciting, especially thanks to my wonderful classmates (who, surprisingly, are of all age-groups, including some quite near my own) and my teachers, who have been very supportive and understanding. How well I will do is something that remains to be seen, but so far, I am enjoying this new journey and look forward to where it leads.

Now that you know the background, you probably get an idea of how and why I am reviewing a book which is obviously on Philosophy. However, before you think that this is going to be a post filled with philosophy jargon, let me reassure you…. This is not going to be a technical review, and the only reason it appears here on the blog is because it relates to what I have been writing about for all these years. So do read on, and I would love to hear what you think of it.





 

The story of this review begins last week. It was our last day of class before the Diwali vacation (yes, I have Diwali vacations now!!) and Sharmila ma’am, who teaches us Contemporary Indian Philosophy (which involves the philosophy of Lokmanya Tilak, G.G. Agarkar and R.D Ranade among others), walked in with a book. She usually brings books related to the philosopher she is teaching, but this time, she said it was her new book, which had just been published. Now, those of you who know me, know that I can’t ever keep my hands off books, especially new ones, so I was among the first to stretch my hand out for it.

And what a surprise it was. I expected a philosophical tome, considering the title. Instead, the first page I turned to, had ten points (yes, bullet points) explaining what is philosophy. I flipped through some more pages, and found more points… and questions…. And more questions. We obviously did not have time to read the book in the class, so I requested her permission to borrow the book to read, and she graciously agreed. Over the next few days, I found myself going over the book every now and then, flipping through the pages, reading at random. It’s a small book, and can be read at one go, but it isn’t the kind of book you read at one go. Its one which is meant to be read slowly, critically. It is meant to provoke thought.

So, what is the book about?

Sharmila ma’am says she was inspired to write this book during the lockdown, a period when she found herself unable to interact with students as she has been used to. The situation made her think of philosophy in a different way, or rather in a manner different from what is usually taught in class, philosophy which we encounter in our everyday life, but from the point of someone who has spent her entire life immersed in philosophy.

The book attempts to answer the kinds of questions those of us who take up philosophy face – Why philosophy? What is philosophy exactly? And so on… and in trying to answer these questions, Dr. Virkar talks of philosophy in various contexts, all of which concern our regular, day to day lives. She speaks of such varied topics such as the Philosophy of Archaeology, of Traffic Management, of Heritage, of Vacations, of Relationships, of Food, of Fun Philosophy and the philosophical analysis of home. She writes about the Philosophy of Tourism and Philosophical Tourism, of the Philosophy of Photography and Philosophical Photography… the list goes on. And she talks of these, not just as topics, by trying to expound on them, but posing questions which can be raised in each of these fields. These questions are by no means complete, they are her questions, but considering her background, they are quite comprehensive.

It is interesting to think of answering a few basic questions with many more, but that is exactly what Dr. Virkar does in the book. Through her topics and questions, she tries to bring out the fact that philosophy is not something that exists outside the world we live in, but it is very much a part of our lives, whether we study it or not, and whether we are aware of it or not.

These questions are meant to provoke thought, which is what philosophy essentially is about.

The book has other, heavier, topics as well, such as Humanity and Humanitarianism, Corporate Yoga, Business Epistemology, Philosophy of Management and Existence at Four Levels. However, each of these topics are dealt in a very simple manner, touching upon topics in an easy language, without going in too deep. Each of these topics is an excellent read, whether you know anything about them or not.

So that’s what the book about. But why did I like it so much?

I was hooked, as soon as I read this from the introduction –

Philosophy is nothing but conceptual geography elucidating interconnections among seemingly unrelated concepts or highlighting the known connections in radically different ways.

I could not have put it better, but this quote summarizes perfectly, my journey from physics to travel writing to aesthetics and heritage to philosophy. Making connections requires asking questions, whether the questions are articulated or not.

My internal questions from my travel experiences, and visiting temples, led me, first to Jnanapravaha Mumbai, where I began to make the connections between what I knew and what I was seeing, through all that I was learning. That led me to the Asiatic, which is where I developed an interest in philosophy, and began to read more about it, which is what has led me to where I am today, and what I am doing now. Where it will lead me next, remains to be seen! But there is no doubt that questions like these are the crux of everything we are, everything we do, whether we are aware of it or not. This only highlights the importance of asking these questions in the first place, of being conscious of these questions, and acting in accordance with them.

There is another aspect of this that I must mention. Samhith, as a student of the IB board, had, as one of his subjects, the Theory of Knowledge (TOK). As part of this, they were encouraged to ask radical questions about how they know what they know. This, I know now, is the essence of Epistemology, but it was taught not as a philosophy, but as critical thinking. During the pandemic, one of the things I enjoyed most, were those discussions with him related to TOK, though I think I learnt more from him than he did from me! Reading this book reminded me of many of those discussions, and made me wish once again, that philosophy was taught to us at school as it was to him! Books like this, and questions like these, will go a long way in bridging that gap. 

P.S. The book was launched today at the University. It will be available online for sale. 

Comments

  1. You very well explained the book and why one should read itπŸ€—

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like your post on explaing the book.Book is moving our mind around the world.I am working as a travel person and i like such kind of post on travel and advanturous
    Give us the change of providing the travel services to persons who wants to travel by self driving the car.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello!!
    Nice post . Thank you for sharing with us.
    Here is the list ofSonalika Tractor Models for Farmers who are looking for the best Sonalika Tractor Models.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Such a great article, thank you for sharing this blog.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for sharing this blog, Keep it up!

    ReplyDelete
  6. This book review on "On Philosophising" by Dr. Sharmila Jayant Virkar offers a concise overview of the content. However, it could be improved by including specific insights or critical analysis of the book's themes, making it more informative for potential readers interested in philosophy and applied philosophy.

    Script Writer

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Thanks so much for stopping by. Please leave a comment for me so that I will know you have been here....

Popular posts from this blog

Gokarna Part II – The Five Lingams

We continued our Gokarna trip by visiting four other Shiva temples in the vicinity, all connected to the same story of Gokarna. The story of Gokarna mentions the Mahabaleshwara Lingam as the one brought from Kailas by Ravana, and kept at this place on the ground by Ganesha. (See my earlier post- Gokarna – Pilgrimage and Pleasure). However, the story does not end here. It is believed that, in his anger, Ravana flung aside the materials which covered the lingam- the casket, its lid, the string around the lingam, and the cloth covering it. All these items became lingams as soon as they touched the ground. These four lingams, along with the main Mahabaleshwara lingam are collectively called the ‘ Panchalingams’ . These are: Mahabaleshwara – the main lingam Sajjeshwar – the casket carrying the lingam. This temple is about 35 Kms from Karwar, and is a 2 hour drive from Gokarna. Dhareshwar – the string covering the lingam. This temple is on NH17, about 45 Kms south of Gokarna. Gunavanteshw

Rama Temple, Gokarna

To my right , the waves rush to the shore, eager to merge with the sand. To my left, the same waves crash against the rocks, their spray diverting my reverie as I ponder over the beauty of nature, and wonder what first brought people here. Was it this beauty that encouraged them to build a temple here, or was it the fresh, sweet spring water flowing from the hill here that made this place special? No matter what the reason, I am glad my auto driver brought me here. We are at the Rama temple in Gokarna, just a few minutes away from the Mahabaleshwara Temple, yet offering so different a perspective.

Pandharpur Yatra 2023

The first time I visited Pandharpur was back in 2007 . The names Vitthal and Pandharpur, were just names to me. I had heard of them, but that was about it. Seeing the lord standing on the brick, hands on his hips, was memorable, but more memorable was the sight that greeted us as we walked out of the main sanctum of the temple. In the mandap just outside were a group of devotees singing abhangs , and dancing. This was the first time I had heard abhangs , and even almost 15 years later, I can remember the welling of feeling within me, listening to the songs, and how fascinated I was by the sight of the devotees dancing, lost in their love of the Lord. Over the years, as I have read more about Vitthal, and participated in Ashadi Ekadashi programmes at Puttaparthi, that first experience has stayed clear in my mind and heart. Every time I tell my Balvikas students of the saints who sang of Vitthala, it is that experience that I re-live. I visited Pandharpur again, in 2010, but that experie